Headed to a hoppin’ salad bar for lunch? Chances are there are a few handfuls of fresh greens up for grabs, from romaine and iceberg to spinach and red leaf. But when it comes to choosing the healthiest salad base, which roughage packs the biggest nutritional punch?
Seeing Green — The Need-To-Know
Sorry sandwich lovers— a few shreds of lettuce on a bun won’t add up to the USDA’s daily recommended intake (2-3 cups for most adults). But a big, healthy salad is one of the smartest ways to go green. Coming in at under 10 calories per cup, a big bowl of leaves can be a stellar source of vitamins A, C, K, and folate, among other essential nutrients.
But don’t think all leafy greens will build a super-nutritious salad. In fact, America’s favorite lettuce, iceberg, ranks the lowest in nutritional value across the board (96 percent water will do that!). Turbo-charged spinach, on the other hand, boasts nearly twice the recommended daily value of vitamin K and half the vitamin A, along with calcium and iron. Clearly, Popeye was on to something.
Prefer a crunchier base? A cup of romaine is a tasty alternative, with a huge dose of vitamin A and a variety of other nutrients. Or, for a mild but textured bed, red leaf lettuce clocks in at just 4 calories per cup, with nearly half of the daily recommended dose of vitamins A and K. Arugula (technically a cruciferous vegetable like broccoli, kale, and cabbage) also packs a healthy dose of nutrients and phytochemicals, which may inhibit the development of certain cancers. And for the non-committal types, mixed greens (typically a mix of romaine, oak leaf lettuce, arugula, frisée, and radicchio) offer, well, a mixed bag of nutritional benefits, depending on the batch.
Winning The Toss – Your Action Plan
Consider visiting the salad bar a free pass to join the dark side. Research shows that “loose” or “open leaf” lettuces (like romaine, red leaf, and butterhead) contain more antioxidants and nutrients than the typically lighter-colored more tightly-packed heads (like iceberg). The reason? Their leaves are able to absorb more light and, in turn, synthesize more vitamins[1]. And while there’s no good way to pick and choose a store-bought salad leaf for leaf, at home, opting for the tops and outer leaves can guarantee a more nutritious base.
Ready to go darker still? While they’re not stocked at most salad bars, check the produce aisle for tougher roughage like Swiss chard and kale, which beat out even spinach in the antioxidant game. Be sure to give the leaves a good cold rinse before serving raw, boiled, or steamed, as the folds in these greens tend to accumulate dirt more easily than other veggies. Also keep in mind that high heat can strip veggies of their natural vitamin content[2]. The final key to becoming a lean, green fighting machine? Dress for success— hold off on the creamy dressing, croutons, bacon bits, and layers of shredded cheese. Instead, opt for a lighter vinaigrette and a sprinkling of chopped walnuts or sunflower seeds for added crunch and protein.
Further Resources
Mayo Clinic — Build a Savvy Salad
Consider this Salad 101.
USDA — Why is it Important to Eat Vegetables?
Finally, some good reasons why.
Eating Well — Healthy Salad Recipes and Cooking Tips
Spice up your usual salad recipes.
The New York Times — How to Beat the Salad Bar
Are salad bars ripping us off?
- Impact of light variation on development of photoprotection, antioxidants, and nutritional value in Lactuca sativa LZhou, Y.H., Zhang, Y.Y., Zhao, X., et al. Department of Horticulture, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 2009, Jun 24; 57(12): 5494-500. [↩]
- Potential of commonly consumed green leafy vegetables for their antioxidant capacity and its linkage with the micronutrient profile.Tarwadi, K., Agte, V. Biometry and Nutrition Group, Agharkar Research Institute, Maharashtra, India. International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition 2003 Nov; 54(6): 417-25. [↩]


















[...] How To Choose The Healthiest Salad Greens [...]
[...] Romaine and spinach and red leaf, oh my! When it comes to creating the healthiest salad, it all starts with a bed of greens. For less than 10 calories a cup, the right leaves can provide a lot of vitamins A, C, and K. Not to mention each green brings a different taste and texture to the plate. Find out more at our article, How to Choose The Healthiest Salad Green. [...]
[...] College of Nutrition 2010; 20(2): 168S-185S.)). There are plenty of boil-free ways to enjoy this leafy green, from a spinach salad with tomatoes, cucumber, and feta to polenta and spinach soup. Or try a twist [...]