Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic: Which Is Better?

Casper and Tempur-Pedic are easily recognizable mattress brands. But which one will give you the bed of your dreams… without breaking the bank?

We did the homework, and you can look at our answers! Read on for key differences, top product recs, and tips on picking the right mattress for your needs.

Share on Pinterest

Comparing the key features of Casper and Tempur-Pedic mattresses is a great place to start when picking your fave.

Bottom line: Casper mattresses are cheaper than Tempur-Pedic. There’s almost a $1,000 difference between the two brands’ lowest-priced mattresses. But there are some perks to paying more.

For example, Tempur-Pedic offers free white-glove delivery, including help setting up your new mattress. With Casper, you’ll get free shipping but have to pay extra for help getting your new bed settled. Both companies have free return shipping.

Knowing you’re getting a quality product is an important part of mattress shopping. Even budget-friendly mattresses can be a meaningful investment.

Materials

Both Casper and Tempur-Pedic mattresses are made with high quality materials.

Casper mattress covers are made with a blend of fibers including polyester, recycled materials, upcycled cotton, and spandex. The company suggests this blend makes its mattress covers stretchy and breathable. The mattresses also contain certified foam.

Most Tempur-Pedic models have at least two layers of certified TEMPUR foam, which the brand suggests is the secret to their comfort and high levels of motion isolation.

Certifications

Both Tempur-Pedic and Casper mattresses have CertiPUR-US certified foams, which means they’re free from certain chemicals and heavy metals.

Both brands also sell mattresses that meet the federal government standards for flammability deterrents, as governed by 16 CRF 1633 and 1632. That’s an important indicator of safety that you don’t want to go without.

To find the mattress of your dreams, it’s important to know a couple of things first:

1) Are you a side, back, or stomach sleeper?

2) How much are you willing to invest in your fab new mattress?

Focusing on these questions can help you sift through all your options to pick the mattress that best suits your needs and budget.

Tempur-Pedic

• Ideal for back/side sleepers. The classic Tempur-Adapt mattress may be too soft for some stomach sleepers, but it might do wonders for you if you sleep on your side or your back (hello, comfort!).
• Customizable. Overall, Tempur-Pedic mattresses have more options, allowing you to choose a support level (soft, medium, firm, etc.) or even the “cooling level” you want in your mattress.

Casper

• Budget-friendly. If price is a sticking point for you, a Casper mattress might be your best bet.
• Ideal if you have back pain. The Casper Original mattress is classified as medium/medium-firm, so it’s a good one to consider if you have back pain. A 2015 study suggests medium-firm mattresses may be best for spinal alignment and improved comfort while you’re sleeping.

For this list, we looked at some of the top mattresses Tempur-Pedic and Casper offer, focusing on quality, cost, firmness, and type. Browse through our best picks to find the mattress that’ll help you doze off.

Casper mattresses

Casper Original Mattress

Price: $
Mattress type: Memory foam or hybrid

The most popular model in the Casper family is the Casper Original mattress. This affordable bed is available as all-foam or hybrid. It also includes cool features like three “support zones” with different firmness levels to help you align your spine and reduce back pain or other aches.

If you opt for the all-foam version, you can expect a mattress with a soft foam base, whereas the hybrid comes with an encased coil spring base that can give you that extra bounce effect.

Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress

Price: $$
Mattress type: Hybrid (foam and springs)

Tired AF of waking up in pain every day? Say hello to your new sleeping buddy! The Casper Wave Hybrid mattress is firmer than the Original model, which is great if you need that extra support to sleep better.

This model also comes with ergonomic zones, which have incorporated gel pods to help alleviate annoying body aches. The three layers of breathable foam with cooling gel promise to cool down your #HotBod and help you wake up feeling refreshed.

Tempur-Pedic mattresses

TEMPUR-Adapt Mattress

Price: $$
Mattress type: Memory foam or hybrid

Reach for the stars with the Tempur-Pedic Adapt mattress! This classic Tempur-Pedic model is available in all-foam and hybrid versions.

Though both versions use the brand’s famed pressure-relieving material developed by NASA, reviewers say the all-foam Adapt mattress provides a gentle feel, whereas the hybrid has 1,000 spring coils that’ll give you more of a bounce effect.

TEMPUR-ProAdapt Mattress

Price: $$
Mattress type: Memory foam or hybrid

A bit on the pricier side, we have the upgraded version of the previous Tempur-Pedic model: the Tempur-Pedic ProAdapt. This one has the same key features as the Adapt model but comes with some extras, such as a zip-off cover that promises a cooling effect.

You can also choose from four mattress feel options instead of just two — soft, medium, medium-hybrid, and firm.

Casper and Tempur-Pedic are both prestigious brands that offer high quality mattresses designed to help you sleep better by improving your spinal alignment and giving you the level of back support you need.

While both brands offer safe, high quality products, Casper has more budget-friendly options and Tempur-Pedic comes with more personalized service.