We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Here’s our process.
Sealy and Serta are two of the most recognizable brands in American-made bedding. But which one is right for you? We’re here to help you dissect the coils from the memory foam and choose a mattress you’ll want to cozy up to every night.
Finding the right mattress for you matters because getting enough sleep allows your brain to be at its best. Both Serta and Sealy are mattress makers that have plenty of experience developing these important products.
Sealy was established in 1881 in Sealy, Texas. Stearns & Foster and Tempur-Pedic mattresses are also part of the Sealy family of brands.
Serta is based in Atlanta, and has been manufacturing mattresses in the U.S. since 1931. Other mattress brands in the Serta family are Simmons, Beautyrest, and Tuft & Needle. Here’s a side-by-side look at what you can expect from Sealy and Serta.
Prices are pretty comparable between Serta and Sealy, but Serta takes the edge. A base model queen-size Serta Luxe mattress is priced at $449, a budget-friendly deal from a brand with a good reputation. For $100 to 200 you can upgrade this model to add support or a cooling features.
For Serta’s mid- and high-priced mattresses, you can also add on upgrades at a few hundred dollars a pop to customize your bed exactly the way you want it.
Sealy mattresses sport a few features that might persuade you to their side.
For one, Sealy has been using “Posturepedic technology” since 1950. They call it “reinforced support where you need it most.” This means the middle section of Sealy mattresses is more supportive. (Middle as in the part by your butt, so it helps even if you sleep with a partner.)
Another feature that might draw you to Sealy is its Response line of mattresses. If you prefer the old school feel of an innerspring mattress over memory foam or a hybrid of foam and coils, Response is your best option.
Both Serta and Sealy have the same range of firmness ratings from ultra/extra firm to ultra plush (aka soft), with the highest number of mattresses in the firm and plush categories.
If you like medium firmness or prefer something at the “ultra” end of the spectrum, Serta has more options, including mattresses with a pillow top to further customize your sleep experience.
With their 120-day trial (versus 100 days with Sealy), Serta gives you just a little longer to return a new mattress if it’s not a good match for your sleep style.
Another plus from Serta: all of their mattresses can be purchased online directly through the Serta website. Sealy, however, has several mattresses that can only be purchased in their store.
Sealy is one of the oldest mattress manufacturers in North America. Daniel Haynes started making cotton-filled mattresses in Sealy, Texas, in 1881. When he invented a machine to compress cotton, Sealy mattresses were born.
Customers rave about comfort and customer service for each of Sealy’s products.
Whether you choose to go with Sealy or Serta, there are plenty of options in a range of prices, comfort preferences, and upgrades.
Best Sealy mattresses for 2021
- Price: $699 (queen size)
- Mattress type: memory foam
This quality mattress ships for free and you can even return it for free if you don’t love it.
You can order the Chill Memory Foam bed directly from Sealy’s website, while you’ll need to find a retailer to buy other options. It comes with a cooling cover wrapping several layers of foam built to give you support without being too firm.
- Price: $2,499 (queen size, plush feel)
- Mattress type: hybrid
Choose the ultra plush option to sleep in the clouds. This hybrid mattress starts with a layer of encased coils. The middle section of the mattress has more coils for more support where most of your body weight rests.
The memory foam layer is breathable and cooling, and the mattress cover is made to protect against allergens. A coil border reinforces the edge of the mattress.
Best Serta mattresses for 2021
- Price: $449 (queen size)
- Mattress type: hybrid
Supportive coils are topped with three layers of memory foam to provide comfort and cooling. The perimeter of the mattress is reinforced with foam edges. This model is plush and 11.5 inches thick. Reviewers loved its soft yet supportive feel and found that it helped them wake up back pain-free.
- Price: $1599 (queen size)
- Mattress type: hybrid
Upgrade the basic Perfect Sleeper to include three layers of memory foam and a pillow top for 17 inches of medium or plush comfort.
Encased coils are topped with layers of memory foam for cooling, pressure-relieving, and comfort. It’s all surrounded by dense foam edging and covered with a breathable cooling fabric.
Sealy and Serta mattresses are comparable across the board. Both companies have a long history of customer satisfaction and a wide range of prices, but they have unique mattress technologies and shopping experiences that set them apart.
Both companies sell mattresses that are made in the U.S. and are CertiPUR-US certified, meaning they’re independently certified to meet standards for safety.
We looked deep into the details of Serta and Sealy mattress lines so you don’t lose any sleep over choosing the best mattress for you.