Go Old School With This Super Thoughtful (and Free!) Valentine’s Day Gift

Stayed Up All Night

READ THIS NEXT {{displayTitle}} READ There are so many ways to show your boo/bae/main squeeze (or whatever kids are calling their significant others these days) how much they mean to you. And there’s also a ton of pressure to get the perfect gift on Valentine’s Day. Personalized gifts are a surefire way to get major brownie points, especially when everyone else is giving candy and flowers. But we’re not exactly DIY masters. Luckily for us, there’s Stayed Up All Night, a super cool website that lets you create and share virtual mixtapes—yes, they even look like cassettes. And did we mention the service is free?

Get ready for some serious ‘90s nostalgia, remixed for the Internet age. Start by selecting the style of tape you want to send and decorating it with doodles, stickers, and a special message. Then, comes the music. Stayed Up All Night syncs with SoundCloud and YouTube and lets you search by song name or artist. Once you’ve crafted the perfect playlist for your special someone (or even just a friend), you can share it with them via email, Twitter, or Facebook. And then wait patiently for a response of blushing emojis because, yes, you’re really the cutest Valentine out there.

READ THIS NEXT: 6 Valentines to Share Love the Greatist Way Overshare Promo